A recipe bucket list, hmmmm this was a tough one for me. I have made so many things already I wasn’t sure what to make but I started thinking and remembered a conversation that I had with a friend of mine Randy, about a polenta that he had while out at a restaurant. A mushroom polenta. When he mentioned that I thought I would have to try it. I had never made a creamy polenta, years ago I had made one that you slice but never a creamy one. I deposited that conversation in the back of my mind to try someday. Well, here is the day!!! I was also recently flipping through a my Fine Cooking magazine and came across this recipe. Exactly what I wanted to try so off I went to make this delicious dish.
Wow was it fantastic. Another recipe for the vegetarian archives. I recently have been upping the vegetarian meals from one to two a week and if they are super delicious like this one I am not hearing complaints from my family as to where the meat is?
Try this around your table, it would make a great side too!! Happy #SundaySupper to everyone!!!
- ½ oz. dried mixed mushrooms or porcini
- 3 Tbsp. butter
- 2 Tbsp. olive oil
- 3 shallots, minced
- Kosher salt
- 2 lb. mixed fresh mushrooms (shitake, portabello, button, cremini, oyster etc.), coarsely chopped
- ½ cup dry vermouth
- 2 Tbsp. heavy cream
- ¼ cup chopped fresh mixed herbs (parsley, tarragon, basil)
- Freshly ground black pepper
- 1⅛ cup cornmeal
- ¼ cup mascarpone
- ½ cup finely grated Parmigiano Reggiano
- ⅓ cup crumbled goat cheese (the one I use had a dusting of spices)
- In a small bowl with 1½ cups warm water soak the dried mushrooms for 10 min. Remove the mushrooms reserving the liquid and coarsely chop. Pour the liquid through a small sieve reserving one cup. Set both aside.
- Meanwhile in a large pot add the butter and olive oil and heat over medium heat, when the butter is melted add the shallots and saute until tender, about 4 min.
- Add the fresh mushrooms and 1 tsp. salt. Cook until they start to soften, 6 min. Add the dried mushrooms and continue cooking for about 4 min. more or until the mushrooms have released their liquid and are very tender.
- Add the vermouth and cook until it is evaporated about 2 min. more. Add the reserved mushroom water from the dried mushrooms and reduce to ⅓ cup. Stir in the heavy cream and 3 Tbsp. of the herbs. Adjust seasoning with salt and pepper. Keep warm.
- In a medium pot bring 4½ cups of water to a boil and add cornmeal, 1 tsp. salt and stir. Cover and cook for 5 min. stirring occasionally. Whisk if needed to make it smooth. Whisk in the remaining 2 Tbsp. butter and the mascarpone. Add the parmesan and stir with a spoon.
- Serve the polenta with the mushrooms on top, sprinkled with the remaining herbs and the goat cheese.
Adapted from Fine Cooking Magazine
This week’s Sunday Supper is all about trying something new, something that’s been on your bucket list but you have yet to tackle. We have had so much fun with this and can’t wait to share these recipes with you!
Join us this Sunday at 7 pm Eastern Time on Twitter as we share our bucket list recipes during our #SundaySupper chat.
The variety of recipes this week is incredible. Many different cuisines are featured. There is something for everyone:
Sunday Supper Specialty Breads:
- Homemade Bagels with Mimosa Spread by Daily Dish Recipes
- Homemade Tortillas by Supper for a Steal
- Brioche by Gotta Get Baked
- Alton Brown’s Soft Pretzels by Hezzi-D’s Book and Cooks
- Braided Challah by The Girl in the Little Red Kitchen
- Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Bites by In the Kitchen with Audrey and Maurene
- Belgian Waffles by Cindy’s Recipes and Writings
- Gluten-free Bread by Happy Baking Days
- Monkey Bread by Vintage Kitchen Notes
Sunday Supper Main Dishes:
- Lightened Up Slow Cooker Butter Chicken by The Meltaways
- Gluten Free Ravioli by No One Likes Crumbley Cookies
- Bagna Cauda and Potatoes by Shockingly Delicious
- Beef Wellington by Family Foodie
- Green Chili and Lentil Tamales by Mangoes and Chutney
- Mushroom Ragout over Creamy Polenta by Noshing with the Nolands
- Butternut Squash Gnocchi by Peanut Butter and Peppers
- Ropa Vieja by Magnolia Days
- Tah-Dig (Persian Rice) by The Little Ferraro Kitchen
- Fresh Ravioli with Ricotta by Comfy Cuisine
- Stuffed Artichokes by The Roxx Box
- Braised Short Ribs by The Messy Baker blog
- Julia Child’s Boeuf Bourguignon by Hip Foodie Mom
- French Onion Soup by The Weekend Gourmet
- Leaping Frog Chicken by The Urban Mrs.
- Fried Polenta with Spicy Tomato Relish by Mama Mommy Mom
- Savory Spinach-Filled Crepe Cake with Cheddar Sauce by Webicurean
- Japanese-Style Prosperity Pockets & Goat Cheese En Croute by Ninja Baking
- San Antonio Puffy Tacos by Sustainable Dad
- Chinese Dumplings by My Cute Bride
- Falafel by Small Wallet Big Appetite
Sunday Supper Desserts and Snacks:
- Creamy Lemon Fudge by Chocolate Moosey
- Zebra Cake by That Skinny Chick Can Bake
- Faux Ice Cream with Bananas by Country Girl in the Village
- Divinity by Juanita’s Cocina
- Homemade Seafoam Candy by girlichef
- French Macarons by I Run for Wine
- Mocha Macadamia Trifle with Mascarpone Cream by The Foodie Army Wife
- Nut and Seed Nougat by What Smells So Good
- Pumpkin Mocha Cupcakes with Whipped Cream Frosting and Dulce de Leche Drizzle by Damn Delicious
- Chocolate Meringue Cake (gluten free) by Dinners, Dishes and Desserts
- Gluten-Free Golden Fudge Cake by Cupcakes & Kale Chips
- Orange Rum Tiramisu Cake by Crispy Bits & Burnt Ends
- Peanut Sesame Honey Brittle by Sue’s Nutrition Buzz
- Granola Bars with Dried Fruit by The Wimpy Vegetarian
- Jamaican Blue Drawers by Lovely Pantry
- Mini Classic Key Lime Pies by In the Kitchen with KP
- Donuts: Redux by Kelly Bakes
- Hot Lemon Curd Soufflés by Food Lust People Love
- Popcorn with truffle oil and asiago cheese by Ruffles & Truffles
Are you ready to tackle your culinary bucket list? I’m one down and lots to go. Perhaps my next one will be a recipe in today’s event. They all look so good. Choices, choices…
Join the #SundaySupper conversation on twitter each Sunday. We tweet throughout the day and share recipes from all over the world. Our weekly chat starts at 7:00 pm ET and you do not want to miss out on the fun. Follow the #SundaySupper hashtag and remember to include it in your tweets to join in the chat. Check out our #SundaySupper Pinterest board for more fabulous recipes and food photos.
Would you like to join the Sunday Supper Movement? It’s easy. You can sign up by clicking here → Sunday Supper Movement.




Love this! Polenta is also on my bucket list too – I just have not had a chance to get around to it. I think that has to change ASAP with this recipe here!
Thanks so much, it was very very good. All of us loved it!!
This looks gorgeous! Loving the fact that you’re doing more veggie recipes!
Thanks for coming over Becca, we do love our vegetarian meals!!
Oh Tara, three of ,y favorite things – mushrooms, polenta. And goat cheese. Can I come over for dinner? Hubby will only eat small amounts of mushrooms if they are in a dish, and prefers polenta cooked thick so it can be sliced.
The goat cheese was not in the original recipe but I thought it would go really well and I was right. Added that extra oomph!
Pingback: Ropa Vieja Recipe for #SundaySupper
Pingback: Easy Homemade Bagels with Mimosa Cream Cheese Spread | The Daily Dish Recipes
Pingback: Donuts: redux for #SundaySupper | kelly bakes
Pingback: Popcorn with truffle oil and asiago cheese for #SundaySupper | She likes ruffles, he likes truffles
I still need to make polenta. As a Southern gal I’ve made plenty of grits which is similar. I do enjoy the creaminess of polenta and should tackle it soon.
I guess grits would be on my bucket list as I have never made those. Thanks for coming over Renee.
Pingback: Belgian Waffles for #SundaySupper - Cindy's Recipes and Writings
Pingback: Braided Challah #SundaySupper - The Girl in the Little Red KitchenThe Girl in the Little Red Kitchen
Pingback: Beef Wellington
Pingback: Sunday Supper
Pingback: #GlutenFree Golden Fudge Cake for #SundaySupper Recipe #BucketList — Cupcakes & Kale Chips
Pingback: Chocolate Meringue Cake (gluten free) #SundaySupper | Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts
Oh wow – now this looks like an insanely amazing dish! I have never made polenta at home, but in New York a few months ago my husband and I split an order of creamy polenta with mushrooms at Scarpetta and it was absolutely amazingggg. I want to try your version – my husband would freak out (in a good way, of course!)!
I hope you and hubby enjoy it!!
Pingback: Divinity ~ Bucket List #SundaySupper! | Juanita's Cocina
Pingback: Deep Fried Polenta with a Spicy Tomato Relish #SundaySupper | Mama.Mommy.Mom.
Pingback: San Antonio Puffy Tacos for #SundaySupper
Oh looks fabulous Tara…. so delicious!
Thanks so much for coming over Nicole!
Polenta is so popular here, I grew up eating it with melted cheese inisde and a tomato sauce on top. The mushroom idea is amazing, they pair so well together! Love this recipe Tara!
Thanks so much Paula, I would love to try it with tomato sauce and cheese, yummy!!
Pinned. And my stomach is growling.
Thanks so much Jen!
Pingback: Mini Classic Key Lime Pies #SundaySupper #BucketList
Pingback: Savory Spinach-Filled Crepe Cake w/Cheddar Sauce #SundaySupper - Webicurean | Webicurean
Beautiful dish. I haven’t tried a polenta at home for almost 20 years. It was all the rage back in the mid-90s when people were rediscovering it, not that it has gone away. A great polenta, and yours look perfect, is not easy. Thanks for sharing perhaps it is time I make some polenta soon.
Thanks so much for coming over Chris, I hope you do try it soon!!
I love the primal earthiness of soft polenta…and I can only imagine how perfectly a mushroom ragout would accent that. This looks like pure comfort. So delicious!
It was a great hearty dish, hubby didn’t miss the meat at all!
I’ll have to bring this to Randy’s attention! Did you you the grainy Purity cornmeal or the more finely ground stuff?
The grainy Purity and I think Randy and yourself would love this recipe!!
Pingback: Julia Child’s Boeuf Bourguignon for #SundaySupperHip Foodie Mom | Hip Foodie Mom
This looks like an amazingly delicious and filling vegetarian main! Definitely good to keep in mind.
It is a hearty meal, thanks for coming over!!
I don’t think I’d miss the meat one bit! Your mushroom ragout over polenta looks amazing!!!
Thanks Liz, it was really good!! You don’t miss the meat at all!!
I adore polenta and can’t wait to try the mushroom ragout! It looks fabulous!
Thanks so much Isabel, and thanks for coming over!!
Wow, this is so gourmet!
Thanks for coming over Sarah, it is but yet pretty simple!
Pingback: 30AEATS » Best Cornbread You Will Ever Eat! #Sunday Supper
Love anything with mushrooms, so pretty sure will love this. looks and sounds so yumm ! Great job !
Thanks so much for coming over, happy #SundaySupper
This look delicious Tara! Porcini mushrooms really bring it over the top. Trying Polenta soon!
I love using different dried mushrooms they add so much more flavor!!
Pingback: Mangoes and ChutneyGreen Chili and Lentil Tamales
Pingback: Homemade Tortillas for #SundaySupper - Supper for a Steal
Oh I love polenta! And with mushrooms it’s really perfect. I’m always on the lookout for vegetarian meals, and this is a keeper. Thanks!!
Thanks for coming over, I hope you enjoy it!!
Pingback: Mocha Macadamia Trifle with Mascarpone Cream | For a Foodie Bucket List #SundaySupper | The Foodie Army Wife
Pingback: Jamaican Blue Drawers | Lovely Pantry
I love polenta and enjoy making it. I love how dressed up this is…mushroom ragout sounds great!!! Absolutely declicious!
Thanks for coming over Lyn, have a Sunday!!
I am pinning this! it looks wonderful and I like that it’s meatless too!
Thanks for the pin!!
I adore polenta and can’t get enough of mushrooms. I’m excited to try your recipe, it turned out beautifully!!
Thank you so much Julia, I hope you enjoy it!!
Pingback: Brioche for a #SundaySupper Bucket List | gotta get baked
I have wanted to make polenta for a bit as well. I purchased a roll that you slice for a recipe but was unimpressed. This recipe sounds amazing! We are trying to move to a more plant based diet and this recipe will be perfect.
Thanks so much, I hope you enjoy it!!
I’ve never had polenta – I know, I know, pathetic right?! Everyone tells me how delicious it is and looking at your photos makes me want to scoop a giant spoonful into my mouth. This sounds hearty, comforting and the perfect vegetarian meal. Plus, I LOVE the combination of different mushrooms – yum!
Thanks Nancy, you will have to try polenta soon!
Your mushroom ragout over creamy polenta is perfect winter fare, Tara. Love how you’ve got all those varieties of mushrooms, herbs and cheeses. Thanks to you I now have a gourmet vegetarian recipe in my file.
Thanks so much for coming over and I am so glad you liked it!!
Another FANTASTIC mushroom recipe!! This is certainly a dish that I’m adding to my recipe bucket list… such a neat idea! Thanks for sharing and keep them coming Tara!
-Shannon
I thought you would like that Shannon, thanks for coming over. Have a great day!!
I’ve always wanted to make polenta but I am afraid to do so. I am so making this to get over my fears!
It is just as easy as making porridge. Nothing to fear but fear itself. I hope you like it!!
Mmmmmmm polenta! And a mushroom polenta at that! Love this! I have also started incorporating more vegetarian dishes at my house too. . cheers to you!
Thanks so much Alice, have a great day!!
Grits = polenta. This recipe sounds great!
Thanks so much!!
Pingback: Orange Rum Tiramisu cake 2013 culinary bucket list #SundaySupper | Crispy Bits & Burnt Ends
Wow, wow, wow! That is pretty much all I can say right now as my mouth is watering big time over this one. 2012 saw me attempt and fail at polenta 4 times but this dish looks so amazing that I think it is worth giving it a try again.
Thanks so much Laura, hopefully it will work really well for you. Cheers, Tara
I am in love with this one – I am huge fan of anything with mushrooms, and creamy polenta is a favorite of mine too!
Thanks so much Erin!!
Oooohhhh polenta, how do I love thee? Let me count the ways… and while I’m at it, let me add this dish to the list because mushrooms are one of my favorite veggies and I’m always looking for new ways to serve polenta. This sounds absolutely perfect!
Thanks for coming over Kelly, have a great day!!
I love polenta and with the mushroon ragout this is a keeper, Tara!
Thanks so much for coming over, it really was very good!!
I am so glad you deposited that conversation with your friend. I have to admit that I have never tried polenta and I am dieing to try it now! Looks gorgeous!
Thanks so much Sarah for coming by, have a great evening!!
Pingback: Friday Pin-Ups: Comforting Stews for Rainy Day Blues | Crumb: A Food Blog
Creamy polenta is one of my favorite dishes. I do not make it often enough. Time to get stirring! Happy Sunday, Tara!
Thanks for coming over Karen. We really enjoyed this and will have to do it again!
Pingback: Creamy Lemon Fudge | Chocolate Moosey